| ITINERANT METHODIST MINISTERS: |
1899 – 1900 Rev. J.G. Anderson |
| 1854 – 1855 Rev. Bateman and Rev. Preston |
1901 Rev. James Jack |
|
1901 – 1904 Rev. R.J. Campbell |
| EARLY PASTORS FIRST CHURCH |
1904 – 1908 Rev. William Hough |
| 1854 – 1857 Presbyterian Elder Peter Kelly |
1908 Rev. Tom A. Handley |
| 1858 Rev. Robert Kellan |
1908 – 1916 Rev. James Melville Fisher |
| 1859 Rev. Joel Burnell |
1916 – 1922 Rev. H.P. Ingram |
|
1922 – 1923 Rev. John Thompson |
| PRESBYTERIAN PASTORS |
1923 – 1927 Rev. T.H. Davies |
| November 6, 1859 Congregation applied and was |
1928 – 1931 Rev. George H. Proctor |
| received into the San Francisco Presbytery |
1931 – 1935 Rev. S. Martin Eidsath |
| Rev. James Pierpont, Organizing minister |
1935 – 1937 Rev. Victor S. Mackay |
|
1937 – 1940 Rev. Thomas W. Heald |
| 1861 – 1864 Rev. David McClure |
1940 – 1942 Rev. Robert H. Smith |
| 1864 – 1870 Rev. Samuel P. Whiting |
1942 – 1945 Rev. Floyd J. Feaver |
| 1870 – 1874 Rev. Charles S. Dewing |
1945 – 1947 Rev. Norman R. Smith |
| 1874 – 1875 Rev. D.K. Nesbit |
1947 – 1952 Rev. John M. Kooyers |
| 1875 – 1878 Rev. W.R. Stewart |
1952 – 1957 Rev. S. Martin Eidsath |
| 1878 – 1882 Serving short intervals: |
1958 – 1962 Rev. Alfred Bryce Sidebotham |
| —– Rev. M. Halliday |
1962 – 1966 Rev. David Ng |
| —– Rev. Thomas Kirkland |
1967 – 1972 Rev. John K. Tritenbach |
| —– Rev. Klinke |
1973 – 1983 Rev. Ronald R. Garton |
| —– Rev. Rap |
1979 – 1984 Assoc. Rev. Grant McLean |
| —— Rev. A.C. Gillis |
1985 – 1992 Rev. Dale Ridenour |
| —– Student: S.W. Pollack |
1993 – 2002 Parish Associate Rev. Sasha Makovkin |
| —– Rev. A.E. Thomson |
1994 – 2004 Rev. William L. Mangrum |
| —– Rev. George McClellan |
2007 – 2014 Rev. Dr. Donald McCullough |
| 1882 – 1885 Rev. James Drum |
20015 – Current Rev. Matthew E. Davis |
| 1885 – 1890 Rev. J.P. Rich |
INTERIM PASTORS |
| 1890 – 1891 Rev. M.A. Starr |
1966 – 1967 Rev. S. Martin Eidsath |
| 1892 – 1893 Rev. J.F. Berry |
1983 – 1985 Rev. Hugh D. Peniston |
| 1894 Rev. John S. Ross |
1984 – 1985 Assist. Rev. Betty A. Hamilton |
| 1894 – 1896 Rev. Elijah L. Burnett |
1985 Rev. Keith M. Hood |
| 1896 Student: William S. Wilson |
1992 – 1993 Rev. Susan Fleenor |
| 1896 – 1899 Rev. James L. Wood |
2005 – 2007 Rev. William McGuinness |
|
2007 – Rev. Larry Ballinger |
